April 17, 2026

The Yankees Keep Letting Games Get Away The Exact Same Way

Yankees

by

Let’s be real — the Yankees never actually had control of this game.

The Angels punched first. Oswald Peraza — yeah, that Oswald Peraza — came right back into Yankee Stadium and took Max Fried deep in the first inning. Just like that, the Yankees were chasing.

They responded, sure. Aaron Judge crushed another first-inning homer. Giancarlo Stanton gave them a lead in the third. For a couple innings, it felt like maybe they could wrestle control back.

But it never felt secure. Not with Mike Trout on the field. Not the way this series was going.

This “They Always Win When Judge And Stanton Homer” Thing? Yeah… Not This Time

History says when Judge and Stanton both go deep, the Yankees win. It’s basically automatic. They came into this game 53-7 in those situations.

Make it 53-8.

Advertisement
ADVERTISE WITH NYYNEWS

Because this wasn’t a normal game. This was the Mike Trout series.

Five home runs in four games. At Yankee Stadium. Let that sink in.

He didn’t just beat the Yankees — he put on one of the best series performances you will ever see in this building. Homering again in the seventh, walking three times, controlling the pace of the game every single time he stepped in.

You cannot make this stuff up.

The Yankees Got The Lead — And Immediately Lost It

Stanton’s two-run shot in the third gave the Yankees a 3-2 lead. That should have been the turning point. That should have been where they settled in.

Instead, it lasted a blink.

The Angels kept grinding at-bats. Fried never really had command. And then the sixth inning showed up and flipped the entire game.

Peraza again. Double. Damage. Chaos.

Four runs. Lead gone. Momentum gone.

You might also like...

And from that point on, the Yankees were not coming back.

The Bullpen Didn’t Just Struggle — It Opened The Floodgates

This is where the real concern is starting to show.

Fried battled, but the bullpen turned a tight game into a blowout. Angel Chivilli served up Trout’s bomb in the seventh. Ryan Yarbrough tried to navigate the eighth, walked into a mess, and Jo Adell ended it with a grand slam.

Game over. No drama. No fight back.

Just another inning where everything snowballs and nobody stops it.

This Series Said A Lot — And None Of It Was Comfortable

Yeah, technically it’s a split.

But don’t let that fool you.

The Yankees got exposed in this series. The bullpen is shaky. The pitching finally gave up the long ball — a lot of it. And when things start to tilt, this team still has not shown it can slam the brakes.

Meanwhile, Trout walked into the Bronx and reminded everyone exactly who he is.

Five homers. Historic territory. Complete control of the series.

Even Stanton said it — you have to acknowledge greatness.

And the Yankees? They just had to survive it.

Except on Thursday, they didn’t.

Felix Pantaleón Avatar

Felix Pantaleón

Founder

Born in Manhattan, New York, Felix Pantaleon is a Dominican-American digital content creator and the founder of NYYNEWS, one of the first and longest-running independent New York Yankees content creator platforms, active since 2005.

LinkedIn Instagram YouTube
Fact Checked & Editorial Guidelines
Reviewed by: Subject Matter Experts

Tags:

You may also like...

Trends

What's Trending
New York Yankees
  1. Max Fried placed on IL with a bone bruise, raising concerns for the team's pitching rotation.
  2. Yankees secured a 5-2 victory against the Mets in their Subway Series opener.
  3. Rookie Spencer Jones expresses his enthusiasm for the upcoming match against the Mets.
  4. A former Yankees player is thriving with his new MLB team after recent release.
  5. Concerns about team consistency arise as Yankees navigate critical moments against rivals.
Overall Trend Summary

The New York Yankees are facing a challenging time as they kick off their Subway Series against the New York Mets. With recent developments including injuries and notable performances, the team is under pressure as they navigate through this pivotal point in the season.

Injury Concerns

The Yankees announced that starter Max Fried has been placed on the Injured List due to a bone bruise on his left elbow. This development comes at a critical moment ahead of the Subway Series, where the Yankees are looking to secure important wins against their crosstown rivals. Aaron Boone has indicated decisions regarding team adjustments as they cope with this loss.

Rookie Spotlight

In positive news, rookie Spencer Jones shared a heartfelt message on social media ahead of the game, reflecting his excitement and gratitude for playing in such a meaningful matchup. His performance could be pivotal as the Yankees look to rally their troops.

Subway Series Outcomes

In the first game of the Subway Series, the Yankees achieved a 5-2 victory over the Mets, thanks to standout performances from players like Cam Schlittler and Ben Rice. This win is crucial for the Yankees as they attempt to gain momentum and solidify their position in the standings.

Player Updates

Of note, a former Yankees player who was recently released has found success with a new MLB team, highlighting the ongoing changes in the Yankees organization amid their current struggles.

Critical Matchup Ahead

As the Yankees prepare for their upcoming games against the Mets, there are concerns within the fanbase regarding the team's consistency and ability to perform under pressure. With challenges and injuries mounting, the next few games will serve as a true test for the pinstripes.

Updated: Sat, 16 May 2026 04:15:27 UTC

2026 AL EAST STANDINGS

TeamWLWin%GB
Loading standings...