Yankees

The Yankees’ Pitching Is Elite. Their Record Doesn’t Tell the Whole Story — Inside the Numbers Behind the Yankees’ Strange Season

By ••4 min read
The Yankees’ Pitching Is Elite. Their Record Doesn’t Tell the Whole Story — Inside the Numbers Behind the Yankees’ Strange Season

AI Overview

The Yankees entered Saturday 80-61, four games behind the Rays despite MLB’s best team ERA at 3.23 and a +114 run differential. Their approximate Pythagorean record is 83-58, while Tampa Bay’s 84-57 record exceeds its roughly 75-66 projection, reflecting close-game results and sequencing. New York’s inconsistent offense—.234 batting average, a near-bottom on-base percentage and 192 home runs—has kept its elite pitching from translating into first place.

Pitching is supposed to win baseball games.

And if you looked at what the Yankees have done on the mound in 2026, you would probably assume they would be running away with the American League East.

They aren’t.

With the Yankees sitting at 80-61 entering Saturday’s game in San Diego, they are still four games behind the Tampa Bay Rays for first place. New York is, however, comfortably sitting in the top American League Wild Card position.

And that is what makes this Yankees season so strange.

The pitching has been good enough to win the division.

Actually, it’s been better than good.

The Yankees have a 3.23 team ERA, the best mark in MLB, while allowing roughly 3.72 runs per game. They have also built a +114 run differential.

Cam Schlittler has emerged as a legitimate Cy Young candidate, going 12-6 with a 2.04 ERA, 171.2 innings and 210 strikeouts. Max Fried has posted a 2.73 ERA in 95.2 innings, while Gerrit Cole has a 3.29 ERA in 104 innings.

Carlos Rodón has been solid when available, and the bullpen has been just as impressive.

Paul Blackburn has a 1.72 ERA. Brent Headrick is sitting at 1.93. David Bednar has a 2.64 ERA and 31 saves.

This is the type of pitching staff that is supposed to carry a team.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement

And it has.

Just not all the way to first place.

The Yankees Are Better Than Their Record

Here’s where the numbers get interesting.

Based on their runs scored and runs allowed, the Yankees’ Pythagorean record is approximately 83-58.

They’re 80-61.

That’s roughly three wins below what their run differential says they should have.

Now look at Tampa Bay.

The Rays are 84-57, but their run differential is only around +46. Their Pythagorean record is approximately 75-66.

That means Tampa Bay has won roughly nine more games than its run differential would suggest.

That’s baseball.

Sometimes you score four runs and win. Sometimes you score nine and win by seven. Sometimes you score three and lose 4-3.

The Yankees have had too many of those games go the wrong way.

The Rays have had them go the right way.

That’s sequencing. That’s close-game performance. That’s variance. Call it whatever you want.

Over 162 games, the math usually catches up.

But we’re already in September.

The Offense Has Made Life Harder

The Yankees’ pitching staff has been good enough to survive plenty of offensive inconsistency, but the lineup hasn’t made things easy.

New York has crushed the baseball, ranking near the top of MLB with 192 home runs.

But they’re also sitting near the bottom of the league in batting average at .234 and around 25th in on-base percentage.

That’s the problem.

This offense can score seven runs in a game and make you wonder how anybody is going to beat them.

Then they can turn around and get held to two or three runs while the pitching staff does everything possible to keep them in the game.

It’s why that +114 run differential doesn’t completely show up in the standings.

The Yankees are winning games by big margins when everything clicks, but they’ve also dropped games where one timely hit could have completely changed the outcome.

So, Does Pitching Win?

Yes.

But pitching doesn’t control everything.

A starting pitcher can throw seven dominant innings and still watch his team lose 2-1. A bullpen can hold an opponent scoreless and still take a loss because the offense couldn’t push a runner across.

And that’s essentially what has happened to the Yankees at different points this season.

Their pitching has given them the foundation of a championship-caliber team.

But the Rays have been on the other side of the coin, winning an absurd number of close games and turning a modest run differential into an 84-57 record.

That’s why the Yankees are four games out despite having one of the best pitching staffs in baseball.

There are still three weeks left.

And that’s the part that should make Tampa Bay uncomfortable.

If the Yankees’ offense becomes a little more consistent and the close-game results start moving toward what the underlying numbers suggest, that four-game gap can disappear quickly.

Because when you look underneath the standings, the Yankees don’t look like a team that should be chasing the division.

They look like a team that should be leading it.

The pitching has already done its job. Now the Yankees need the rest of the baseball gods to cooperate.

NYY.NEWS SHOP - MEMORABILIA, CLOTHING & MORE