by The Yankees trusted their catching plan, and right now, it looks like one of the ugliest spots on the roster.
The Yankees have a catcher problem. Not a small one. Not one of those little “give it time” problems people like to throw around when they don’t want to admit what is right in front of them.
This has been bad. Really bad.
Austin Wells was supposed to be the guy. Former top prospect. Left-handed bat. Power upside. Good enough behind the plate. The whole thing sounded nice when the Yankees were selling it.
But at some point, you have to stop selling the idea and start looking at the player.
Austin Wells and JC Escarra hands down are the worst catching unit I have ever watched on the Yankees in my life.
— Everything Yankees (@eyyankees) June 4, 2026
Austin Wells has become a lineup hole
Wells has not just struggled. He has been a dead spot in the order. The average is buried under .200. The OPS is ugly. The strikeouts kept showing up. The at-bats looked the same too many nights.
And this is where I go back to what I said a few weeks ago. I said it then, and I’ll say it again now: the Yankees historically do not operate like this at catcher.
We are talking about a franchise that had Yogi Berra, Thurman Munson, Jorge Posada, Mike Stanley, Joe Girardi, Jim Leyritz, Russell Martin, Brian McCann, Gary Sánchez before the fall-off, and even Jose Trevino gave them something useful.
The Yankees have had catchers who could defend. They have had catchers who could hit. They have had catchers who could at least survive offensively.
What they have right now is not that.
Yes, Wells can receive. Yes, the Yankees value his framing. Yes, pitchers seem comfortable with him. That matters.
But let’s not act like catching defense makes a .160 hitter disappear from the box score. It does not. Especially when this lineup is already dealing with injuries and needing help from places they did not expect.
The injury makes it even messier
Now Wells is on the 10-day IL with cervical headaches, and obviously, when it comes to the neck and head area, you hope the guy is alright first. Baseball takes a back seat there.
But roster-wise, this makes the Yankees’ catching situation look even more ridiculous.
J.C. Escarra gets optioned, then right back up he comes because Wells lands on the IL. Ali Sánchez gets brought in as a right-handed catching option. Suddenly, the Yankees are shuffling chairs behind the plate like they are trying to survive a bad spring training split-squad game.
That is not a World Series setup.
Escarra has not fixed anything either
And before anybody says Escarra deserved more run, let’s be real about that too. He has not hit either.
Escarra is a good story. Older player, worked his way up, left-handed bat, pitchers like him, respectable receiver. Fine. Nobody is taking that away from him.
But the Yankees do not need a good story right now. They need production.
Escarra has not brought power. He has not brought consistency. He has not forced the Yankees to say, “This guy has to play every day.”
That is the problem. Wells was struggling. Escarra was struggling. Sánchez is not some magic answer. And Ben Rice, who actually hits, has become too important offensively to just toss back there every day like nothing matters.
This goes back to roster valuation
This is where Brian Cashman always gets people fired up.
The Yankees made a bet. They bet on Wells. They moved catching depth. They rolled the dice that their catching factory would keep producing enough behind the plate while Wells’ bat developed.
Well, where is the bat?
This is the same frustration fans had with Anthony Volpe. The Yankees fall in love with the internal evaluation. They keep giving runway. They keep saying the underlying stuff is there. They keep waiting.
Meanwhile, the big-league team is trying to win games right now.
You cannot keep punting offense at important positions and then act shocked when fans get tired of watching automatic outs.
The Yankees need to stop pretending this is fine
The defense is not the issue. The catching instruction is not the issue. The Yankees know how to build defensive catchers.
The issue is simple: they are not getting enough offense from the position.
And when you are the New York Yankees, with the history this franchise has had behind the plate, it looks even worse.
This is not some random position for this organization. Catcher has always mattered here. Leadership, toughness, big swings, big moments. That has been part of the Yankees’ identity forever.
Right now, it is a black hole.
Maybe Wells comes back healthy and finally starts hitting. Maybe Escarra finds something. Maybe Sánchez gives them a small spark. Maybe Rice becomes part of the answer later if the roster opens up differently.
But the Yankees cannot just sit there and hope.
They need to be looking outside the organization. They need to be honest about Wells. They need to stop acting like defense alone covers everything.
Because right now, the catching situation is not just disappointing.
It is embarrassing.
And for a team trying to win the division, trying to survive injuries, and trying to convince people this roster is good enough for October, that is a problem they better fix before it gets louder.
NYY.NEWS SHOP - MEMORABILIA, CLOTHING & MORE
-
MLB NEW YORK YANKEES CITY ARCH MEN’S SJ TEE (MIDNIGHT NAVY)
$55.00 Buy Now -
MLB NEW YORK YANKEES RETRO CLASSICS MEN’S RIB FLC PO HOODIE (EGGSHELL/ MIDNIGHT NAVY)
$130.00 Buy Now -
Women’s Concepts Sport White New York Yankees Infuse Knit Top
$46.99 Buy Now -
MLB NEW YORK YANKEES MODERN ORIGINALS MEN’S LS RUGBY (MIDNIGHT NAVY)
$95.00 Buy Now -
Tervis New York Yankees 24oz. Batter Up Acrylic Tumbler
$23.99 Buy Now -
MLB NEW YORK YANKEES LETTERMAN MEN’S BUTTON DOWN (WHITE/MIDNIGHT NAVY)
$130.00 Buy Now -
Men’s Navy New York Yankees Fastball Pullover Hoodie
$64.99 Buy Now -
Women’s Levelwear Black New York Yankees Influx Sizzle T-Shirt
$35.00 Buy Now
