Murderers’ Row – Inside the 1927 Yankees
(Original Caption) Murderers' Row, 1931 edition...The four members of the New York Yankees who will strike terror to the heart of any pitcher they may face this season during the race for the pennant. They are, left to right, Lou Gehrig, first baseman; Earl Combs, outfielder; Tony Lazzeri, second baseman, and Babe Ruth, outfielder.

Murderers’ Row – Inside the 1927 Yankees

The Greatest Team in Baseball History?

The 1927 New York Yankees are the gold standard of baseball dominance — a team so stacked, so feared, and so successful that their nickname, “Murderers’ Row,” still echoes through the halls of Yankee Stadium nearly a century later. But what made this team so legendary? Let’s step inside the clubhouse of the most iconic squad in Major League Baseball history.

A Lineup That Struck Fear

The term “Murderers’ Row” was originally used to describe the top half of the Yankees’ batting order — a brutal gauntlet of hitters that pitchers dreaded facing. These weren’t just good players — they were elite, with multiple future Hall of Famers and league-leading stats:

Top of the Order:

  • Earle Combs (CF): Hit .356 with 231 hits and 137 runs scored.

  • Mark Koenig (SS): A .285 hitter with solid defense and base running.

The Heart of the Order – Murderers’ Row:

  • Babe Ruth (RF): Hit a record-setting 60 home runs, drove in 165 RBIs, and had a staggering .772 slugging percentage.

  • Lou Gehrig (1B): Batted .373 with 47 home runs and 175 RBIs. Yes, 175 RBIs.

  • Bob Meusel (LF): Drove in 103 runs with a .337 average.

  • Tony Lazzeri (2B): Hit 18 home runs and knocked in 102 RBIs as a 23-year-old rookie.

Every single one of those hitters could (and did) take over games. There were no breaks for opposing pitchers — just one punishing bat after another.

Pitching to Match the Bats

As overwhelming as the offense was, the pitching staff was elite too. The Yankees led the American League in ERA (3.20) and shutouts (11).

  • Waite Hoyt (RHP): 22–7 record with a 2.63 ERA

  • Urban Shocker (RHP): 18 wins

  • Herb Pennock (LHP): 19–8 record

  • Wilcy Moore (RHP): A standout rookie reliever with 19 wins and 13 saves — unheard of at the time

In an era before modern bullpens, this staff carried the load from April to October with remarkable consistency.

Team Accomplishments – 1927 Season Highlights

  • Record: 110–44 (.714 winning percentage)

  • AL Pennant: Won by 19 games

  • World Series: Swept the Pittsburgh Pirates in 4 games

  • Runs Scored: 975

  • Runs Allowed: 599

  • Run Differential: +376 (!)

The Yankees didn’t just win — they crushed the opposition. They led the league in virtually every offensive category and dominated the postseason without losing a game.

Why the 1927 Yankees Are Still the GOAT

Sports debates are endless, but many historians, analysts, and fans still consider the ’27 Yankees the greatest team ever assembled. Why?

  • Depth: All-stars in every position.

  • Star Power: Ruth and Gehrig were transcendent talents.

  • Dominance: They beat opponents in every way — power, pitching, speed, and defense.

  • Cultural Impact: Their nickname, “Murderers’ Row,” became part of the American lexicon.

Even in today’s advanced analytics era, the 1927 Yankees hold up. Their numbers weren’t just great for the time — they’re great for any era.

Legacy

The ’27 Yankees laid the foundation for the Yankees dynasty that would stretch for decades. They made winning the expectation in the Bronx and raised the bar for what a baseball team could be. Whether you’re a fan of old-school legends or modern sabermetrics, one thing’s clear: Murderers’ Row was as real as it gets.




RSS Latest Yankees News

Links