Ken Rosenthal Says What Yankees Fans Have Been Screaming for Years: Stop Wasting Aaron Judge’s Prime

Ken Rosenthal finally said the quiet part out loud, and honestly, it felt overdue.

The Yankees cannot keep pretending they are doing enough while Aaron Judge is still playing at an MVP level. You can spin playoff appearances all you want, but as Rosenthal pointed out, at some point you actually have to see the Yankees put their best foot forward.

Judge is not some 25-year-old prospect with infinite time. He is 33, heading toward 34, and while he still looks like a baseball god right now, that window does not stay open forever. Yankee fans understand that. Apparently, the front office is still trying to convince itself otherwise.

Aaron Judge Is at His Peak, Not in a Waiting Room

Rosenthal made it clear that Judge is coming off one of the best seasons of his career, if not the best. This is the moment. This is when organizations go all in. This is when you surround your generational superstar with the best possible roster, not just a roster that sneaks into October and hopes for good vibes.

And yes, the Yankees keep making the playoffs. Nobody is denying that. But fans are not asking for “good enough.” They are asking for a legitimate championship push while Judge is still capable of carrying a franchise on his back.

That is where the frustration comes from. That is why this conversation keeps happening every single winter.

The Yankees can’t keep continuing to not put their best foot forward with Aaron Judge in his prime, says @Ken_Rosenthal.

“I expect they’re going to do things, but at some point you have to see it.” pic.twitter.com/QJ36dfpx6Y

— Foul Territory (@FoulTerritoryTV) January 5, 2026

The Yankees Know the Problem, So Why Is It Still a Problem?

Rosenthal even acknowledged what the Yankees have tried to do. They went hard after Juan Soto last year. They signed Max Fried. They brought in Cody Bellinger. These are not nothing moves.

But here is the issue. What happens if those plans fall apart? What happens if Bellinger does not happen? What happens if the next big target slips through their fingers again?

That is where the concern starts creeping back in. Because good intentions do not win championships. Completed rosters do.

The $300 Million Line Is a Self-Imposed Excuse

Hal Steinbrenner has made it very clear he does not want to cross the $300 million payroll threshold. He has said the Yankees can build a winner without getting there.

Technically, he is not wrong.

But here is the reality. The Yankees finished last season around $296 million. Right now, they are sitting closer to $263 million. That is a massive gap. That is clear room for a $30 million player, if not more.

So when fans hear that number and then look at the roster, the math does not add up. If the money is there and the mission is to win, what exactly are we waiting for?

Time Is Not Over, But Time Is Not Infinite Either

Rosenthal was fair about one thing. The offseason is not over. Not even close. There are still moves to be made, still dominoes to fall, still opportunities to improve this team.

But that does not mean the Yankees get a free pass. Every day that goes by without a clear statement move is another reminder that Judge’s prime is not slowing down for payroll spreadsheets.

At some point, fans need to see action, not projections, not explanations, not optimism.

The Yankees know what their mission is. They know the clock is ticking. And they know Aaron Judge deserves more than half-measures.

Now they actually have to prove it.