Media vs. Yankees Fans: Joel Sherman Sparks a Familiar Fight

There’s a moment every season when the conversation around the Yankees stops being about baseball and starts being about who’s allowed to be mad. This week, that moment arrived courtesy of Joel Sherman.

On Talkin’ Yanks, the longtime New York Post writer unloaded on what he called “whiners” in the Yankees fanbase — fans who questioned whether re-signing Trent Grisham meant Hal Steinbrenner would get cheap and let Cody Bellinger walk. Sherman didn’t mince words:

“Will any of those people shut the f*** up now? They will not shut the fuck up because they like that lane that’s either stupid or they enjoy being stupid, like because they get attention.”

That didn’t land the way he probably thought it would.

Let’s be clear upfront: NYYNEWS has long respected Joel Sherman. He’s informed, plugged in, and one of the few national voices who actually understands how the Yankees operate. This isn’t a hit piece. But on this topic? This take isn’t it.

Because the problem isn’t fans being “misinformed.”
The problem is fans being dismissed.

“Will any of those people shut the fuck up now? They will not shut the fuck up.”

The New York Post’s Joel Sherman says Hal Steinbrenner made Yankees fans eat their words pic.twitter.com/94oMheVBW9

— Talkin’ Yanks (@TalkinYanks) January 27, 2026

The Straw Man Argument

Fans weren’t inventing a conspiracy theory for clicks. They were reacting to history. A 17-year championship drought. A front office that routinely frames spending as sacrifice. A pattern of “run it back” seasons followed by October disappointment.

Calling that concern “stupid” doesn’t engage with it — it sidesteps it.

As one fan put it bluntly:

“Joel Sherman is attacking a straw man so he can continue getting access to the Yankees.”

That may sound harsh, but it gets at something real. When criticism gets reframed as ignorance, accountability disappears. Suddenly, the fans are the problem — not the roster construction, not the philosophical ceiling, not the refusal to aggressively upgrade when the window is open.

I think what’s even dumber is having the means to spend, but not spending wisely. 17 years and counting. https://t.co/qCe9uyIya6

— Felix | NYY.NEWS (@_NYYNEWS) January 27, 2026

Same Team, Louder Spin

Yes, the Yankees are spending. Yes, Cody Bellinger is back. And yes, the luxury tax payroll is massive — projected to land just north of $330 million, the highest they’ve ever entered a season with.

But context matters.

Bellinger’s luxury tax hit for 2026 will be $48.55 million. That’s real money. It also doesn’t magically fix an offense that stalled, stagnated, and vanished when it mattered most last year.

Fans aren’t angry because the Yankees didn’t spend.
They’re angry because the spending isn’t strategic.

Running back the same core while already over the luxury tax threshold isn’t bold. It’s expensive inertia.

As one fan summed it up:

“Running back the same team when already over luxury tax threshold anyway doesn’t improve the team. Spend more to improve offense.”

That’s not whining. That’s analysis.

The Media–Fan Disconnect

This whole episode ties directly into something we’ve already covered at NYYNEWS — the growing gap between the organization, its megaphones, and the people footing the bill.

If this feels familiar, it should.
We’ve seen this tone before from the Yankees’ own voices, where valid frustration gets brushed off as noise.

Yankees Front Office vs the Fans: Why Boone and Kay Sound Like Career Politicians Right Now

Different messengers. Same message: trust us, stop complaining.

That’s where the resentment comes from.

Loving the Team ≠ Blind Loyalty

Here’s the part that keeps getting lost: Yankees fans aren’t casual observers. They’re emotionally, financially, and culturally invested. They show up. They spend. They care — sometimes obnoxiously, sometimes irrationally, but always passionately.

Dismissing that passion as stupidity is how you widen the divide.

One fan nailed it:

“Don’t let them fool you the media hate the fans that spend their time and money on the team. I may not like how fans talk about their teams but the reality is people like Joel Sherman have contempt for the fans.”

That may be overstated, but the feeling didn’t come from nowhere.

Don’t let them fool you the media hate the fans that spend their time and money on the team. I may not like how fans talk about their teams but the reality is people like Joel Sherman have contempt for the fans. https://t.co/u1HQgcT3fJ

— Baseball Hut (@TheBaseballHut) January 28, 2026

Final Thought

You can respect Joel Sherman and still say he swung and missed here.

Fans aren’t asking to “shut the f*** up.”
They’re asking for ambition that matches the payroll.
They’re asking for accountability that matches the rhetoric.
They’re asking why having the means doesn’t always translate into spending wisely.

Or, as we put it at NYYNEWS:

I think what’s even dumber is having the means to spend, but not spending wisely. 17 years and counting.

That’s not whining.
That’s the sound of a fanbase that remembers what winning used to feel like — and refuses to accept less just because the bill is high.