Yankees Face Tough Choice as Devin Williams Draws Interest from Marlins

The New York Yankees enter the offseason with a 94-68 record, but looming free agency could see two-time All-Star reliever Devin Williams depart after a challenging first season in the Bronx.

Williams, acquired from Milwaukee last winter, was expected to be a stabilizing force in the bullpen. Instead, he struggled with a 4.79 ERA over 67 appearances this season, ultimately losing his closer role due to inconsistency and command issues. The Yankees relied more on David Bednar, who may need to step up as a true closer if Williams decides to leave.

Reports are surfacing that the Miami Marlins are eyeing Williams as a potential acquisition, seeing him as a buy-low opportunity to bolster their struggling bullpen. After moving from 62 wins in 2024 to 79 wins in 2025, the Marlins still ranked just 22nd in MLB with a 4.28 bullpen ERA. They are looking for a dependable late-game option, and Williams fits that description, even after a rocky year.

The Yankees’ window to negotiate with Williams is shrinking, especially with interest from teams like the Marlins and the Cardinals. Miami’s willingness to offer him the chance to reclaim a closer role could make them the frontrunners. That’s a significant incentive, considering Williams’ potential to dominate when on his game.

Williams expressed his openness to re-sign with New York but acknowledged that negotiations involve both parties. Does that mean the Yankees are ready to invest in a reliever who had a down year? With the offseason in full swing, they must act quickly to protect their roster.

Marlins Eyeing Williams for Bullpen Strengthening

The Miami Marlins have identified Devin Williams as a valuable asset to enhance their bullpen. Their current roster features Calvin Faucher, who converted 15 of 18 save opportunities, but they lack a true shutdown presence. Williams could fill that role effectively.

Despite a rocky season in New York, Williams still showcased his talent by striking out 90 batters and maintaining a 34.7% strikeout rate, ranking in the 97th percentile across MLB. The Marlins see an opportunity to tap into his high-upside potential at a manageable salary.

New York’s Growing Concerns Over Bullpen Depth

The Yankees are in a precarious position if Williams decides to walk. With an early playoff exit and a need for reliable middle relief options, losing a player with his strikeout ability would deepen their offseason challenges. The team still appears to be weighing their options and may need to consider other closers this winter.

Manager Aaron Boone relied heavily on Bednar in crucial situations. However, if the Yankees pursue a more established closer like Robert Suarez from San Diego, Bednar may need to shift to a setup role. The bullpen uncertainty looms large as the Yankees look at their offseason strategy.

Williams’ Potential Departure: A Missed Opportunity?

If Williams leaves for Miami or another team, it would mark a sharp turn from the Yankees’ plans for his role. The promise of reclaiming a closer role is a strong motivator for Williams; after all, nothing drives a reliever’s value quite like late-game success.

Yet, even in a season filled with ups and downs, Williams’ underlying metrics suggest his potential for a stronger comeback. With a 2.68 FIP, he still demonstrated the ability to dominate hitters, making his offseason decision all the more critical for both him and the Yankees.

Free Agency: What’s Next for the Yankees?

As Williams inches closer to free agency, the Yankees must act swiftly to bolster their roster. A return on investment with Williams could be key, but the market is frenzied, and rival teams are circling.

Beyond Williams, the Yankees have other holes to fill in the lineup, making this offseason a pivotal moment. The combination of factors—injuries, inconsistent performances, and gaps in the lineup—means they have their work cut out for them.

It’s official: the Yankees have a lot of work to do this offseason. After a 94-68 finish, it’s time to confront the reality of free agency and roster decisions. And right at the top of that list is Devin Williams. Will the two-time All-Star find greener pastures in Miami, or will the Yankees manage to keep him in the fold?

Unraveling the Williams Situation

Devin Williams’ inaugural season in pinstripes was anything but what anyone hoped for. With a shaky 4.79 ERA over 67 appearances, Williams lost the closer role due to inconsistent performance. The Yankees acquired him to fortify their bullpen, but now he stands at a crossroads. The Miami Marlins are interested, and they have an enticing offer on the table—could this really be the end of Williams in a Yankees uniform?

Williams struck out 90 batters this season and boasted a 34.7% strikeout rate, ranking in the 97th percentile across MLB. So why did things fall apart? It’s a classic case of New York pressure versus a player’s ability to thrive. As he looks toward free agency, will he prioritize a role in a more forgiving environment?

Opportunity Knocks for New Faces

For the Yankees, the potential loss of Williams opens the door for other pitchers. David Bednar has proven his worth and may need to step up as the team’s anchor in the bullpen. Yet, the clock is ticking. They must assess their options and potentially scout the trade market for a big-name closer like Robert Suarez. With injuries lingering and other prospect roles to consider, could this be the perfect time for a shake-up?

Brian Cashman is under pressure to make the right moves this offseason. Relying heavily on Bednar at the end of the season isn’t enough. The organization needs dependable arms, especially if they let Williams walk. But the question remains: can they turn to younger talent in their system, or do they need to dip into free agency to fill the gaps?

Meanwhile, Williams has publicly expressed some level of interest in re-signing with the Yankees. However, he’s also made it clear: “It takes two parties for that.” And with teams like the Cardinals and Marlins circling, the competition is fierce. Will the Yankees secure a deal before it’s too late?

As fans, The club have to keep the Yankees’ eyes on the offseason moves that could define the Yankees’ future. Will they sink or swim in the sea of free agency? Get ready to engage—your voice matters. How do you think the Yankees should approach this offseason? Let’s hear your thoughts!

What Does the Future Hold for Devin Williams?

For Williams, the crossroads are evident. He has expressed interest in remaining in New York but has not ruled out opportunities with other teams, especially those promising the ninth-inning role. With the Marlins’ offer on the table, he needs to weigh his options carefully.

Whatever decision he makes, it will have ramifications for the Yankees’ bullpen strategy moving forward. Can New York provide the right incentives to keep him? Or will Williams be the latest player to slip through their fingers as they try to navigate an unpredictable offseason?

stay tuned and stay vocal. The offseason is about to heat up, and every decision matters. Let the Yankees know The club’re ready for action—let’s see what they do next!