1999 Cy Young Pedro Martinez vs 2022 MVP Aaron Judge. Who Would Win? You Decide!

NYYNEWS.com

• Yankees' Bullpen Gamble: Is Dylan Coleman the Answer or Just Another Pipe Dream? January 27, 2026
  The Yankees have officially turned their backs on the starting pitching market this offseason, as noted by MLB insider Mark Feinsand. With names like Framber Valdez and Chris Bassitt slipping through their fingers, fans are left wondering just how deep the front office's commitment to improvement truly runs. In a rather under-the-radar move, the Yankees […]
• Yankees Lock in Bellinger: What’s Next? January 27, 2026
  The Yankees have officially signed Cody Bellinger to a lucrative five-year contract worth $162.5 million. This move, while significant, raises more questions than it answers about the team’s overall strategy moving forward. Bellinger’s deal includes two opt-outs, which could give him leverage depending on how he performs. Given his strong 2025 season—where he hit 29 […]
• Yankees Fans Demand More as Jeter Stands by Steinbrenner January 26, 2026
  The Yankees are at a crossroads, and it's becoming increasingly clear that the organization's direction is drawing the ire of its passionate fanbase. With Derek Jeter, a franchise icon, publicly defending Hal Steinbrenner, the question remains: can the Yankees still embody the 'win-now' mentality that has long defined them? Fans are restless. Watching the Dodgers, […]
• Willie Randolph Playfully Trolls Aaron Judge January 26, 2026
  It’s hard to ignore the brilliance of Aaron Judge. Winning his third AL MVP is no small feat, putting him in elite company with Yankees legends like DiMaggio and Mantle. Yet, as the accolades pile up, one glaring question remains: where’s the championship ring? The Yankees are stuck in a paradox. Fans celebrate Judge’s individual […]
• Yankees’ Pitching Depth in Question as Rodón and Cole Recover January 26, 2026
  The New York Yankees are standing at a precipice this offseason. With significant injuries to key pitchers, the need for a resilient rotation has never been more pressing. The health of Carlos Rodón, who is expected to start the 2026 season on the injured list, looms large over the team’s plans. Rodón's journey back from […]
• Aaron Judge's MVP Moment: A Reflection of Yankees Culture and Expectations January 26, 2026
  Another MVP trophy for Aaron Judge, another reminder of the weight he carries as the face of the Yankees. He’s not just a player; he’s a symbol of the franchise’s high expectations and their relentless pursuit of greatness. Accepting his third American League MVP award, Judge stood among a crowd of familiar faces—family, teammates, and […]