The Trade That’s So Obvious For The Yankees, Why Haven’t They Done it Yet?

About three weeks ago, Jack Curry of The Yes Network. (Yankees insider) Came out and said that The Yankees were OUT on Nolan Arenado.

As the off-season has progressed, Arenado’s name keeps popping up (by Yankees fans & insiders alike) on how he would be the logical fit for The Yankees at third base. Nolan recently turned down a trade that would of sent him to Houston.

With names like Ke’Bryan Hayes being mentioned recently & vouched for by Michael Kay.

Yesterday on his new show @RealMichaelKay talked about the Pirates 3B Ke’Bryan Hayes potential fit with the Yankees.

He said his father Charlie was scratching his head a few years ago with some of things they were doing with the hitters in Pittsburgh. pic.twitter.com/Q2XeT5hyji

— Julian Guilarte (@JulianGuilarte1) January 16, 2025

Many have dismissed the idea of trading for Pirates Ke’Bryan Hayes (Son of Former Yankee Charlie Hayes) as someone from the farm system could have a bigger impact offensively. Also, The obvious answer. Nolan Arenado

I don’t understand how people could not want Nolan Arenado for 3 years but then want Ke’Bryan Hayes for 5 years. Just doesn’t make much sense to me

— Earl Bayless (@YankeesFanEarl) January 16, 2025

Jack Curry also reported three weeks ago, that The Yankees were also out on Alex Bregman. But, Arenado remains a hot topic.

Ryan Beck of NYYNEWS

Ruben Cruz of NYYNEWS

Ryan Beck of NYYNEWS

So what’s the hold up? Many say it’s the Yankees inability to trade away Marcus Stroman.

Our 6th Starting Pitcher Marcus Stroman’s $18M salary.

— RocketMan120 (@Rocketman220) January 17, 2025

The New York Yankees have long been known for their aggressive pursuit of top talent, and trading for Nolan Arenado could be a game-changer for the team. Here are a few reasons why the Yankees should make this move:

1. Elite Defensive Skills

Nolan Arenado is widely regarded as one of the best defensive third basemen in baseball. His exceptional fielding ability and strong arm would significantly bolster the Yankees’ infield defense, making it even more difficult for opposing teams to get hits and score runs.

2. Powerful Bat

Arenado brings a potent bat to the lineup. With his ability to hit for both average and power, he would provide a much-needed boost to the Yankees’ offensive production. His presence in the lineup would create more scoring opportunities and put pressure on opposing pitchers.

3. Veteran Leadership

Arenado’s experience and leadership qualities would be invaluable to the Yankees’ young roster. As an eight-time All-Star and a seasoned veteran, he could mentor younger players and help instill a winning mentality within the team.

4. Contract Considerations

While Arenado’s contract is substantial, the Yankees have the financial resources to absorb it. His contract includes three years and $74 million, which is a reasonable investment for a player of his caliber. Additionally, the Yankees could potentially negotiate a deal that includes the Cardinals eating some of the contract, making it even more favorable for New York.

5. Competitive Edge

Adding a player of Arenado’s caliber would give the Yankees a competitive edge over their rivals. With his defensive prowess and offensive firepower, he would make the Yankees a more formidable opponent and increase their chances of winning the World Series.

6. Fan Excitement

Trading for a star player like Arenado would generate excitement among Yankees fans. His arrival would create buzz and anticipation. The energy and enthusiasm from the fans could have a positive impact on the team’s performance.

In conclusion, trading for Nolan Arenado would be a strategic move for the New York Yankees. His elite defensive skills, powerful bat, veteran leadership, and overall impact on the team make him a valuable addition. With the financial resources and competitive drive to make this trade, the Yankees should seriously consider bringing Arenado to the Bronx.