Yankees’ Offseason Priorities: Addressing First Base Challenges and Exploring Nolan Arenado as a Solution

Nolan Arenado: A High-Impact Target

One of the most intriguing possibilities for the Yankees is St. Louis Cardinals third baseman Nolan Arenado. According to reports, Arenado has emerged as a potential trade candidate this offseason and is open to transitioning from third base to first base if necessary. This positional flexibility makes him an appealing target for the Yankees as they evaluate their roster needs.

At 33, Arenado is coming off a slightly underwhelming offensive season, posting a .272/.325/.394 slash line with 16 home runs and 71 RBIs over 152 games. However, his career numbers—341 home runs and a history of consistent run production—underscore his value as a proven offensive threat. Even in a down year, Arenado’s bat could bring much-needed stability and power to the Yankees’ lineup.

Yankees First Base Woes in 2024

A major obstacle for the Yankees last season was the lack of steady contributions from first base. Veteran Anthony Rizzo, who was expected to be a key figure in the lineup, was limited to just 70 games due to injuries. His struggles began with a fractured right forearm on June 18, and later, a hit-by-pitch on September 28 resulted in multiple fractured fingers, officially ending his season.

Even when healthy, Rizzo’s performance at the plate was far below expectations. He recorded a disappointing slash line of .228/.301/.355, managing only eight home runs and 35 RBIs. This steep decline from the 35-year-old prompted the Yankees to decline his $17 million option for the 2025 season, opting instead for a $6 million buyout.

Rizzo’s departure leaves the Yankees with a glaring hole at first base—a position they must solidify if they hope to contend in 2025.

Defensive Excellence: A Key Asset

While Arenado’s offensive abilities are impressive, his defensive reputation sets him apart. Widely regarded as one of the best defensive third basemen in baseball history, Arenado has accumulated 10 Gold Gloves and six Platinum Gloves over his illustrious career. His defensive versatility and elite skill set would give the Yankees multiple options in constructing their infield.

If acquired, Arenado could shift to first base to address the Yankees’ immediate need or remain at third, where his defensive prowess has been unparalleled. This flexibility would allow the team to optimize its infield alignment, potentially moving other players back to their natural positions.

Why Arenado Fits the Yankees’ Plans

For the Yankees, adding Arenado would address multiple challenges at once. His ability to play either corner infield position would provide flexibility, while his power and experience would enhance an offense that lacked consistency in 2024. Furthermore, Arenado’s leadership and team-oriented mindset would likely resonate in a clubhouse aiming to recapture its competitive edge.

Arenado’s openness to a position change aligns perfectly with the Yankees’ need to fill the void at first base. His willingness to adapt highlights a commitment to team success, a trait that could have a positive ripple effect across the roster.

Trade Hurdles and Financial Considerations

Acquiring Arenado would not come without challenges. The Cardinals are unlikely to part with him without receiving significant assets in return. For the Yankees, this might mean surrendering top prospects or established players to secure the deal. Additionally, Arenado’s sizable contract adds another layer of complexity, especially as the Yankees balance other priorities, including Soto’s re-signing.

At 33, Arenado remains a high-level player, but the Yankees must also weigh the long-term implications of acquiring a veteran with a hefty contract. Striking the right balance between immediate success and sustainable roster building will be a key challenge for the front office.

Internal Options: Ben Rice and Oswaldo Cabrera

While the Yankees have internal candidates to consider, their options are limited and unproven. Rookie Ben Rice showed potential during limited action in 2024, while utility player Oswaldo Cabrera offers versatility and athleticism. However, relying on these players for a full-time role would be a gamble for a team with championship aspirations.

Rice, a left-handed hitter with power potential, remains largely untested at the MLB level. Cabrera has demonstrated his ability to adapt to various positions but lacks the profile of a traditional first baseman. While either player could play a role, the Yankees are likely to seek a more experienced solution to stabilize the position.

A Crucial Offseason Awaits

As the Yankees enter what could be a transformative offseason, resolving the first base situation will be a top priority. Whether they opt to promote from within or pursue a high-profile acquisition like Arenado, their decision will shape the team’s trajectory for 2025 and beyond.